Utah People's Post

The Latest News from the Beehive State

Wednesday, June 29, 2022
Log in
  • National News
    • Female Caseworker Killed & Doctor Shot in Philadelphia
  • State News
    • Car Chase Leads to Drug Arrest
  • Tech & Science
  • Health
    • How to Prepare For Ticks Season
    • Magical Weight Loss Bean Scam
  • Sports
  • Business
You are here: Home / Health / Why Should Any Form of Female Genital Mutilation Be Legalized?

Why Should Any Form of Female Genital Mutilation Be Legalized?

February 24, 2016 Posted by Amelia Donovan

female genital mutilation

Two US-based gynecologists argue that legalizing a less severe form of female genital mutilation would protect girls from suffering more extreme procedures. However, the great majority of medics and ethicists are clearly against the proposal.

Why should any form of female genital mutilation be legalized? Why not stop the mutilation that 3 million girls are subjected to every year? This tradition is deeply ingrained in a lot of cultures in Asia, Africa, and the Middle East.

The painful and often anesthesia-free can range in severity from nicking the young girl’s genitals to completely removing her clitoris and labia then stitching up the vagina.

Performing this kind of operations is illegal in the US and the UK, but Kavita Allan Jacobs and Shah Arora, two gynecologists based in New York and Ohio, disagree.

They argue that pushing the procedure underground will pose even more threat to girls. The gynecologists added that trying to wipe it out could be “viewed as racist or culturally insensitive.”

Instead, Jacobs and Arora suggest that a compromise that “respects culture and religion but provides necessary protections against child abuse,” such as operations that won’t affect the girl’s ability to carry a pregnancy later or her long-term sexual satisfaction.

Their controversial proposal suggests doctors could limit the procedure to small cuts or the removal of some parts of the labia or the clitoral hood. Nawal Nour, head of the African Women’s Health Center at the Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts, is not the only one who disagrees with this compromise.

“From a human rights and health care perspective,” she said, “this is a hard pill to swallow.” She argues that the gynecologists have no data suggesting that if a girl is only nicked when she is 6 or 7, she won’t suffer a more severe surgery four or five years later.

At the same time, who’s to say that these proposed minimal procedures will be accepted by the traditional communities that preserve the practice?

In addition, it seems like a gamble to legalize any form of mutilation, even though Arora and Jacobs said smaller nicks will eventually heal completely.

But even smaller surgeries involving FGM can still have a strong psychological impact on the girls, because the “amount of tissue removed does not necessarily correlate with the amount of psychological damage.”

As a last argument against compromising with FGM is that it’s one of those cultural practices that don’t deserve to be respected or preserved.

According to Ruth Macklin, a biomedical ethicist at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine in New York, “female genital alteration has its origin and purpose in controlling women” – a tradition best abandoned.
Image Source: TTEONB Blog

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Email

Filed Under: Health

mm

About Amelia Donovan

Amelia got her feet wet in the captivating world of journalism while still in college, working as the editor of the university’s newspaper. She minored in Journalism and Mass Communication before receiving a scholarship at a prestigious German university. After receiving her bachelor’s degree, Amelia went on to pursue her biggest passions: journalism and science. She enjoys being up to date with any cutting-edge scientific advancements and her minor in biology allowed Amelia to accurately cover particularly interesting medical topics.

Woman working out at the gym

Just 23% of Americans Are Working Out Enough in Their Spare Time

June 29, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Poliovirus Therapy Gives Brain Cancer Patients New Hope (Study)

June 29, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

United Airlines airplane

Passenger Mysteriously Dies on United Airlines flight Bound for Boston

June 28, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Breakfast sandwich

Here Are Some Foods No Nutritionist Would Ever Eat

June 27, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Poppy flower

UN Warns of Surge in Opium-based Drugs and Cocaine Supply

June 27, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

U.S.-Canada border

French Jogger Detained 2 Weeks for Accidentally Crossing Border

June 26, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Plus size model

Normalizing Plus Size Could Fuel Obesity Crisis (Study)

June 25, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Giant manta ray

Unique Manta Ray Nursery Spotted off Texas Coast

June 23, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

The rainbow flag

WHO Scraps Transgenderism from List of Mental Illnesses

June 22, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

456 People Dead at U.K. Hospital after Taking too Many Painkillers

June 21, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Kenyan girls dancing

Kenyans Facing Poor Nutrition as Supermarket Shopping Is on the Rise

June 20, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Pages

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy GDPR
  • Staff
  • Terms and Conditions

Recent Posts

  • Just 23% of Americans Are Working Out Enough in Their Spare Time
  • Poliovirus Therapy Gives Brain Cancer Patients New Hope (Study)
  • Passenger Mysteriously Dies on United Airlines flight Bound for Boston
  • Here Are Some Foods No Nutritionist Would Ever Eat
  • UN Warns of Surge in Opium-based Drugs and Cocaine Supply
  • French Jogger Detained 2 Weeks for Accidentally Crossing Border
  • Normalizing Plus Size Could Fuel Obesity Crisis (Study)

Related Articles

  • Woman working out at the gym

    Just 23% of Americans Are Working Out Enough in Their Spare Time

    Jun 29, 2018
  • Poliovirus Therapy Gives Brain Cancer Patients New Hope (Study)

    Jun 29, 2018
  • Breakfast sandwich

    Here Are Some Foods No Nutritionist Would Ever Eat

    Jun 27, 2018
  • Normalizing Plus Size Could Fuel Obesity Crisis (Study)

    Jun 25, 2018
  • The rainbow flag

    WHO Scraps Transgenderism from List of Mental Illnesses

    Jun 22, 2018
  • 456 People Dead at U.K. Hospital after Taking too Many Painkillers

    Jun 21, 2018
  • Young woman affected by depression

    If You Have PTSD You Were Likely Abused as a Child

    Jun 19, 2018
  • Obese dog on a leash

    Obese Dogs Can Help Us Better Understand How Obesity Works

    Jun 18, 2018
  • Our Brains Are Craving Combinations of Fats and Carbs (Study)

    Jun 15, 2018
  • Hungry bird with beck open

    Scientists Explain Why We Get ‘Hangry’

    Jun 13, 2018

Categories

  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • National News
  • Nature
  • Provo
  • Salt Lake News
  • Science
  • Sports
  • State News
  • Tech & Science
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized
  • West Jordan
  • West Valley City
  • World

Copyright © 2022 utahpeoplespost.com

About · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Site Map · Contact