Utah People's Post

The Latest News from the Beehive State

Sunday, July 3, 2022
Log in
  • National News
    • Female Caseworker Killed & Doctor Shot in Philadelphia
  • State News
    • Car Chase Leads to Drug Arrest
  • Tech & Science
  • Health
    • How to Prepare For Ticks Season
    • Magical Weight Loss Bean Scam
  • Sports
  • Business
You are here: Home / Health / Whole-Genome Scans Not Quite Ready For Widespread Use: Study

Whole-Genome Scans Not Quite Ready For Widespread Use: Study

June 20, 2014 Posted by Staff

Commercially available tests can analyze your genetic profile and try to predict your risk of a host of diseases. But a new study suggests they aren’t ready for prime time. The technology, known as whole-genome sequencing allows scientists to map the information encoded in most of the billions of building blocks that make up a person’s DNA.

So far, whole-genome sequencing has been used mainly in research. But the hope is that the technology will help fuel a new era of personalized medicine where doctors will be able to identify patients with gene variants that raise their risk of certain diseases.

“In the past few years, the cost of whole-genome sequencing has fallen to the point where it could soon be feasible to use it in everyday health care,” said Dr. Frederick Dewey of Stanford University, the lead researcher on the new study. Based on his team’s findings, Dewey said, “A lot more work is needed before that idea becomes reality.”

The study reported in the March 12 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association found that sequencing a whole genome remains a fairly daunting task and although the commercially available tests are good, they aren’t yet reliable enough for routine patient care.

For the study, they used an Illumina platform for sequencing with confirmatory sequencing for 12 participants on the Complete Genomics platform. The researchers used appropriate reference genomes for the 5 white European and 7 East Asian participants and screened genes from many sources including the Human Gene Mutation Database (HGMD).

56 genes that the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics recommended for prioritization in testing because of action ability, 118 gene variants associated with diabetes mellitus type 2 or coronary artery disease and 555 genetic variants associated with drug responses.

A team of 3 genetic counselors, 3 physician informaticists and 1 molecular pathologist curated sequence variants from literature reviews and phenotype identification software that uses allele frequencies, functional classes, and evolutionary conservation to predict pathogenicity.

Team members determined which variants to report to 5 physicians, who then suggested clinical follow-up solely on the basis of the DNA data. Three were academic primary care practitioners, two of whom had no experience with genetics or genomics and the other two were academic medical geneticists.

Overall testing showed that each patient had between 2 million and 3 million unique variations in their DNA. The researchers then used a software program they had developed to whittle down that sea of information to around 100 genetic variations per person that were deemed worthy of more investigation.

“Next, they analyzed those variations in an old-fashioned way by actually sitting down,” Dewey said and sifting through the medical literature and available genetic databases to see which gene variants might be relevant to people’s health.

That process took about an hour per variant at an estimated cost of $17,000 per patient when all was said and done. For each participant, WGS revealed 2 to 6 personal disease-risk findings, most for adult onset conditions from the HGMD. Each participant carried 8 to 18 disease causing recessive alleles. For the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics reportable genes, each participant had 12 to 20 variants which fell to 1 to 7 variants after eliminating sequencing artifacts or common polymorphisms.

Overall the study identified only a single very likely pathogenic gene variant, a 19-base deletion in BRCA1. The woman who did not have a family history of the associated cancers had risk reducing surgery. Eleven of the 12 participants had at least 1 gene variant of pharmacogenetic significance.

The physicians suggested 1 to 3 diagnostic tests and/or referrals per participant with a median cost of $351 to $776 which include a high-complexity established patient visit and 2 hours of genetic counseling.

The researchers conclude that in their study, WGS was associated with incomplete coverage of inherited disease genes, low reproducibility of detection of genetic variation with the highest potential clinical effects and uncertainty about clinically reportable findings.

Limitations of the study include the early stage of applying sequencing data to clinical decision making, lack of full clinical information on the participants and applicability beyond academic medicine.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Email

Filed Under: Health Tagged With: DNA, genetic variations, Genome Scans, Journal of the American Medical Association, whole-genome sequencing

Woman working out at the gym

Just 23% of Americans Are Working Out Enough in Their Spare Time

June 29, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Poliovirus Therapy Gives Brain Cancer Patients New Hope (Study)

June 29, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

United Airlines airplane

Passenger Mysteriously Dies on United Airlines flight Bound for Boston

June 28, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Breakfast sandwich

Here Are Some Foods No Nutritionist Would Ever Eat

June 27, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Poppy flower

UN Warns of Surge in Opium-based Drugs and Cocaine Supply

June 27, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

U.S.-Canada border

French Jogger Detained 2 Weeks for Accidentally Crossing Border

June 26, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Plus size model

Normalizing Plus Size Could Fuel Obesity Crisis (Study)

June 25, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Giant manta ray

Unique Manta Ray Nursery Spotted off Texas Coast

June 23, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

The rainbow flag

WHO Scraps Transgenderism from List of Mental Illnesses

June 22, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

456 People Dead at U.K. Hospital after Taking too Many Painkillers

June 21, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Kenyan girls dancing

Kenyans Facing Poor Nutrition as Supermarket Shopping Is on the Rise

June 20, 2018 By Amelia Donovan

Pages

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy GDPR
  • Staff
  • Terms and Conditions

Recent Posts

  • Just 23% of Americans Are Working Out Enough in Their Spare Time
  • Poliovirus Therapy Gives Brain Cancer Patients New Hope (Study)
  • Passenger Mysteriously Dies on United Airlines flight Bound for Boston
  • Here Are Some Foods No Nutritionist Would Ever Eat
  • UN Warns of Surge in Opium-based Drugs and Cocaine Supply
  • French Jogger Detained 2 Weeks for Accidentally Crossing Border
  • Normalizing Plus Size Could Fuel Obesity Crisis (Study)

Related Articles

  • Woman working out at the gym

    Just 23% of Americans Are Working Out Enough in Their Spare Time

    Jun 29, 2018
  • Poliovirus Therapy Gives Brain Cancer Patients New Hope (Study)

    Jun 29, 2018
  • Breakfast sandwich

    Here Are Some Foods No Nutritionist Would Ever Eat

    Jun 27, 2018
  • Normalizing Plus Size Could Fuel Obesity Crisis (Study)

    Jun 25, 2018
  • The rainbow flag

    WHO Scraps Transgenderism from List of Mental Illnesses

    Jun 22, 2018
  • 456 People Dead at U.K. Hospital after Taking too Many Painkillers

    Jun 21, 2018
  • Young woman affected by depression

    If You Have PTSD You Were Likely Abused as a Child

    Jun 19, 2018
  • Obese dog on a leash

    Obese Dogs Can Help Us Better Understand How Obesity Works

    Jun 18, 2018
  • Our Brains Are Craving Combinations of Fats and Carbs (Study)

    Jun 15, 2018
  • Hungry bird with beck open

    Scientists Explain Why We Get ‘Hangry’

    Jun 13, 2018

Categories

  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • National News
  • Nature
  • Provo
  • Salt Lake News
  • Science
  • Sports
  • State News
  • Tech & Science
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized
  • West Jordan
  • West Valley City
  • World

Copyright © 2022 utahpeoplespost.com

About · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Site Map · Contact